Salt: Good On Fries, But What About Roads?

Posted on October 9, 2009 by Mickey

Tetons 2009 016

The seasons turn quickly in Wyoming, and I don’t mean one day you’re kicking around in sandals and the next day you’ve decided to compliment them with socks. No, here in Grand Teton National Park, where I’m a seasonal ranger, I was standing atop an 11,000-foot peak in short sleeves one day last week and the next day it snowed in the valley, with temps barely scraping forty. In the mountains it was the new snow that won’t melt until next July or possibly August. The date was September 30, and it has snowed several times in the week since. It will snow some more tonight. It’s like somebody flipped a switch: summer one day, winter the next. No fall to speak of.

While the temperatures here are dropping, the level of stress associated with my morning commute is rising. What was once an 18-mile traffic-free cruise through one of the most scenic tableaux in the world is now a white-knuckle crawl on icy roads in the dark, sunrise and the melting point still at least an hour away. It got me thinking about something: the ten million tons of salt that highway departments all across the US are preparing to dump on our roads this winter to make them passable.

Of course, in a national park, where my commute takes place, salt is verboten as a deicer, with sand and gravel filling in as a gritty and inert substitute. This underscores the problems of salt. Anything a national park decides is detrimental to environmental quality is probably something the rest of us should pay attention to. In fact, road salt, not being easily trained, either doesn’t seem to know that it is only meant for roadways or willfully flaunts the boundaries we project on it. Whatever the case, in the act of turning ice into liquid, it tends to wash itself right into streams and groundwater. Anyone familiar with the concepts of saltwater versus freshwater and the fact that they host different species of aquatic life (and rarely the twain shall meet), can probably guess that salinating freshwater bodies is disagreeable to the organisms involved. Amphibians in particular do not fare well. Humans don’t get along terribly well with saltwater, either. We need the fresh stuff, and when road salt runoff contaminates a well of drinking water, that well is done.

Even when it hasn’t yet made it into the water system, salt finds a way to mess with things. It changes the pH of the soil, weakening native plant species and encouraging the establishment of hardier invasives. Still in situ on the blacktop, it attracts wildlife such as deer and moose, creating conflicts with traffic that are dangerous for both the animals and winter drivers.

Eventually, with the exception of what gets licked up by mammals, all ten million tons of road salt will end up in surface streams or groundwater, environments not at all prepared for such an influx of sodium chloride. So what to do?

Well, as I mentioned I’d seen in the parks, sand is one alternative. Of course, the very thing it has going for it – that it’s not a water-soluble chemical – is its biggest drawback, because it doesn’t melt ice. It merely increases friction, and for a very limited time. And then it doesn’t go very far, piling up on roadsides and clogging storm drains.

There are other chemical deicers beside salt, magnesium chloride being one. These seem in many ways safer than salt, but still can negatively impact local environments when applied in quantity. They also tend to be more expensive than good ol’ (toxic) rock salt.

I’d like to end this post with a nice neat suggestion for how to handle icy roads in an environmentally friendly way, but all I can come up with is for us to all park our cars for the winter (whenever that comes to your neighborhood) and strap on skis or skates to get around. Putting stuff (any stuff when it’s ten million pounds of it) on the pavement just isn’t good for anything except drivers. But I have to get up early tomorrow morning and navigate 18 miles of treacherous untreated Jackson Hole black ice, so maybe I’m not qualified to give an unbiased view.

5 Comments +

  1. I live in an area that is lucky to see one snow per year so I have no firsthand knowledge but I wonder why you can’t just use snow tires/chains. I’m completely naive when it comes to the situation but isn’t that what they’re for?

    October 9th, 2009 at 9:55 am
    Comment by Julie
  2. Nice one, Mickey. Particularly the correct usage of ‘verboten’.

    I don’t have an answer either, just want to reinforce that most chemical de-icers aren’t any better than salt. In fact, chemically, Magnesium Chloride IS a salt. I like your idea. Park and ski.

    Or move to the tropics. That’s what I did.

    October 9th, 2009 at 5:17 pm
    Comment by A Free Man
  3. Be careful out there, Mick! Around here, the method is 2 good ole’ boys in the back of a pickup shoveling sand onto the road. Georgia is so progressive.

    October 9th, 2009 at 11:32 pm
    Comment by Lynn
  4. We get lots and lots of snow around here. I always complain about the fact that they rarely plow our road, but I guess the nice thing is that they rarely salt our road. Same goes for side streets in the city of Rochester too, I think. We tend to drive around on packed snow (which gets kind of messy when it melts and then freezes over the cycle of a sunny day). Because we get a lot of snow, we have a lot of 4 wheel drive vehicles around here, and we have a lot of people who are used to driving in snow and know how to handle it. Where I grew up, if there was 1/2 an inch on the ground, everyone had a snow day.

    I don’t really know what the solution is. Maybe solar and wind powered road warmers? :)

    October 10th, 2009 at 10:07 am
    Comment by Allie
  5. Driving in snow five months out of the year (esp in Grand Teton NP) is heavens gift to us mortals! All you need to do is – Slow down, drive an all wheel drive or 4X4 vehicle, with great winter tires (studs, siped, etc), carry a tow rope and have a place front and rear to attach it.

    Thank your lucky stars you aren’t in a snowstorm in Washington, D.C.

    “God bless Wyoming, and keep it wild”.

    October 10th, 2009 at 12:26 pm
    Comment by Bob Robert

Leave a comment

Tip of the Day

If It Doesn’t Smell, Don’t Wash It

19980_m.jpg

According to Real Simple, if every American made an effort to launder less — cutting out just one load of laundry a week per household — we’d save enough water to fill seven million swimming pools each year.

So if it looks clean, and it smells clean, call it clean and wear it again. Consider hanging worn clothes out on your clothesline to freshen them up between wearings.


  • Stay-ad

    Support This Site

    acadiatozion.com

    <Bento Buddy

    UncommonGoods Udon noodle bowl

    Woodgamz.com Cornhole Products

    Greensbury Market brings you certified organic meat as seen on the Oprah Winfrey Show and Jon & Kate Plus 8.

    www.Smallflower.com

    Red Ad

    Sierra Club

    Shop Frontier's wide selection of flavor-packed, certified organic dips and dressing mixes.

    Dr Sears Family Approved

    Alibris

    Alltop, all the cool kids (and me)

    LinkShare  Referral  Prg